The Popularization of
Traditional Music
We tend to place value on popularity,
assuming that the collective judgment of a larger number of people is superior
to a few, or that of an individual. The opposite is often assumed as well, that
if something is not largely popular, it is probably not very good. Combine this
with the fact that the TV, movie and music industries make business decisions
of what they will or will not promote in order to maximize profits, and you can
realize how we might get a very distorted idea of what is or isn't good unless
we rely more on our own good judgment.

For example, the comedian Steve
Martin is extremely well known from TV and movies, but he also plays
Bluegrass banjo. He recently recorded an album, most of which were his original
tunes. The album won the 2010 Grammy Award for Best Bluegrass Album.
I agree that he is a good musician, but I don't believe he is the best player,
or that his compositions were the best tunes recorded that year. What he did
was sell more albums than anyone else due to his popularity, and that
statistically ranked him above many players much better than him, but less well
known.
The tune Shove The Pig's
Foot a Little Further Into the Fire is an old tune which was used in the
soundtrack of the movie Cold Mountain released in 2003, but in
the soundtrack it was renamed "Ruby With The Eyes That Sparkle" to
fit the story. Some clips of this are on YouTube.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JZpnI_kXhaA
I first became aware of the
tune in the late 1990's, after it was recorded on Bruce Molsky's album Big
Hoedown. Bruce credits an older
source, a North Carolina fiddler named Marcus Martin who recorded it as
a duet with his son Wayne some time before 1970.
While some people might feel that hearing a
traditional tune in a major motion picture is good because it increases the
overall awareness of this style, I believe it takes it in the wrong direction.
When I first became interested in fiddling, I only cared about learning to
play, and didn't care too much about where the tunes came from. I eventually
came to realize that the better musicians I knew did care, and they inspired me
to pursue a deeper understanding.

If you respect the music enough to care about the details,
this respect extends to knowing the correct name ( or sometimes more than one
name ) of the tune, who the source of the tune is believed to be, where they're
from, and sometimes some history about the fiddler. Fiddlers often tend to be
fascinating people, and before long you can acquire many good stories about
them to go along with the tunes you play. You may realize that this isn't just
like any other music coming out of a loudspeaker, it is a part of some other
peoples lives. It is something that other people once played with their hands,
maybe a very long time ago.
When recording equipment became portable by the
1940's many tunes were collected by historians from the Library of Congress and
numerous Universities. They traveled across Appalachia to find and record
fiddlers like Marcus Martin (above). More of these are becoming available
online at sites like the The Digital Library of Appalachia
where I found this original clip of Marcus Martin.
Shove The Pig's Foot a
Little Further Into the Fire